Never ask a 5 year old for knitting advice

I showed my Reverse Bloom Flower washcloth to Noey and asked her if it looked like a flower petal. Her response was "No". Not even a little bit? "No" Should I rip it out and start over? "Yes" This is my fourth attempt and I think this is the one. I'm thinking that after 4 attempts I'm not going like it any better!